Analytical Note Using 2020 Financial Inclusion Insights Survey Data
The Financial Inclusion Insights (FII) surveys provide nationally representative demand-side data, trends, and practical insights into the usage of financial services in Pakistan and other countries. Supported by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, six FII surveys have been carried out in Pakistan since 2013. This analytical note is based on the data from the 2020 survey, which included 3,567 individual interviews with adults aged 15 years old or older. The survey was conducted from February to March 2020 until fieldwork was stopped because of government directives aimed at stopping the spread of COVID-19.1 Despite the early fieldwork stoppage, the survey provided statistics that are representative of the national population and also the rural and urban populations separately.
The survey provides detailed measurements of individuals’ financial literacy and awareness and use of formal financial products, including bank and mobile money services. Focusing on digital financial services, the survey also measures trends in mobile phone ownership and use of mobile technology.
For the FII 2020 questionnaire, the FII team carried out a scoping exercise to gauge the information needs of relevant stakeholders in Pakistan. In this regard, the team met with officials at the Central Directorate of National Savings (CDNS). CDNS officials were mainly interested in assessing consumer awareness of its financial products, as well as the customer experience of those who use CDNS products. CDNS products can be purchased at National Savings Centers (NSC), Offices of the State Bank of Pakistan, as well as the Pakistan Post, with varying eligibility criteria for each product. The input from CDNS was formulated into a series of questions, which were incorporated into the FII survey. The following reflects some of the key findings based on the responses to those questions.
1. Awareness of Central Directorate of National Savings (CDNS)
Survey respondents were asked whether they knew about several government organizations, specifically, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP), Pakistan Post, Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA), Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP), and the Central Directorate of National Savings (CDNS). One-in-five (21%) of adults in Pakistan recognized CDNS – fewer than any other government organization queried except for the SECP (see Figure 1).

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.
The survey provides insights into the demographic characteristics of those who are aware or unaware of CDNS. There is a significant gender gap; 28% of men compared to 15% of women recognized CDNS. Similarly, recognition of CDNS varies by urban/rural locality – 32% of urban adults compared to 15% of rural adults recognized the organization.
Survey respondents who were aware of the CDNS were asked about the products and services it offers. Prize bonds were the most widely known product, recognized by 87% of those who were aware of CDNS, followed by savings accounts and savings certificates (see Figure 2). Among the overall sample, only 9% of the adults in Pakistan could identify savings certificates as a CDNS product.

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.
Awareness of CDNS products is highest among the financially included population; 42% of this group were aware of at least one of its products. Among the financially excluded population, only 12% could identify at least one CDNS product. However, even within the financially included group, recognition of CDNS’s savings products was low. Of those respondents who had savings accounts with banks, only 62% knew about the savings account offered by CDNS, while 74% knew about the savings certificates offered by CDNS.
2. Customer Profile
The FII 2020 sample captured only 36 respondents who were CDNS customers2. Figure 3 gives a breakdown of the product preferences of this group; more than half of the customers had purchased prize bonds (62%), while the lowest subscription was that for the savings account (10%).

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.
CDNS customer demographics provide interesting insights. The present CDNS user base is mostly comprised of financially included individuals with higher education. Similarly, the recognition of its brand is also higher among those who are financially included and have higher education.
Forty percent of CDNS customers fell into the 35-to-44-year age bracket and another 23% were between the ages of 45 and 54. This suggests a relative lack of interest in these products from among the younger age brackets, given the overall awareness levels about the CDNS brand is almost the same across all age brackets.
CDNS product users also tend to be more educated than those who are not CDNS customers. Of all the respondents with higher education, 3% were CDNS customers.3 While this is a small proportion of the sample, it is a much greater number when compared with the 0.4% of respondents with no formal education, who were CDNS customers. However, given the small sample, caution is needed in interpreting these results as being representative of the CDNS customer base.
Another interesting aspect is that 74% of CDNS customers were financially included.45 Among this group of financially included CDNS customers, 83% were bank account owners, 44% were mobile wallet account owners, and 27% of the sample said that they subscribed to both bank accounts as well as mobile money accounts.
When asked about their level of satisfaction with CDNS services, more than half of the respondents reported they were “very satisfied” (Figure 4).

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.
Despite this high level of satisfaction, the purchase or use of CDNS products remain low. The main reasons respondents gave for this lack of uptake are shown in Figure 5.

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.
Of those who knew about the CDNS brand, 30% said “I don’t know about CDNS products,” which implies that they didn’t know about it enough to subscribe to its products. Another 9% complained about the registration process being too complicated. Only 3% said they did not have a CDNS branch close by.
Conclusions: The FII 2020 data suggests the CDNS had the lowest name recognition, except for the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan, when compared with other state institutions. The low-level recognition of the CDNS brand is also reflected in the low level of product adoption. Those who have adopted CDNS products tend to be financially included individuals with higher education, and most CDNS customers reported being “very satisfied” or “satisfied” with their experience with CDNS. However, while CDNS brand awareness is high among the highly educated and financially included group, the level of awareness about CDNS products is low among this category of potential CDNS customers. It is very likely that adoption of CDNS products might increase as awareness increases, particularly given the satisfaction level of its existing customers.
Recommendations: CDNS could boost the uptake of its products through marketing designed to increase awareness of its brand and the products and services it offers. Marketing messages should focus on building knowledge of product offerings and understanding on how to access them.
Notes
1 Note: Due to the onset of COVID-19 in Pakistan, the data collection was reduced from its original target of 6,000 individuals.
2 This small number constitutes only 1.1% of the sample, which means that the sample size is not large enough to be used for reliable estimates. Therefore, the findings in this section need to be treated with caution.
3 Higher education includes: diploma (complete and incomplete), college/university degree (complete/incomplete) and post-graduate university education.
4 Financially included individuals are those with a full service account at a financial institution.
5 CDNS customers, who are just holding savings certificates and prize bonds are not considered to be financially included. However, those who have savings accounts are considered to be financially included. More details about the CDNS savings account can be accessed here: http://savings.gov.pk/project/savings-account/
Analytical note dated 25 September 2020. Figures reflect the data available at the time.

Leave a Reply