Analytical Note on Pakistan Post

Analytical Note Using 2020 Financial Inclusion Insights Survey Data

The Financial Inclusion Insights (FII) surveys provide nationally representative demand-side data, trends, and practical insights into the usage of financial services in Pakistan and other countries. Supported by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, six FII surveys have been carried out in Pakistan since 2013. This analytical note is based on the data from the 2020 survey, which included 3,567 individual interviews with adults aged 15 years old or older and was conducted in February-March 2020 until fieldwork was stopped because of government directives aimed at stopping the spread of COVID-19.1 Despite achieving a sample size that was smaller than originally planned, the survey has provided statistics that are representative of the national population and also the rural and urban populations separately.

The survey provides detailed measurements of individuals’ financial literacy and awareness and use of formal financial products, including bank and mobile money services. Focusing on digital financial services, the survey also measures trends in mobile phone ownership and use of mobile technology.

For the FII 2020 questionnaire, the FII team carried out a scoping exercise to gauge the information needs of relevant stakeholders in Pakistan. In this regard, the team met with relevant officials at the Pakistan Post. Pakistan Post officials were mainly interested in using the FII survey to assess the customer experience as well as customer awareness of Pakistan Post’s products and services. The input from Pakistan Post was formulated into a series of survey questions. The following reflects some of the key findings based on the responses to those questions.

1. Awareness of Pakistan Post

Survey respondents were asked whether they knew about government organizations, specifically, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP), Central Directorate of National Savings (CDNS), Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA), Pakistan Post, and the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan. Pakistan Post had the highest level of recognition, at 66%, when compared with the other government entities (Figure 1).

Figure 1: Recognition of government entities by name (N=3,567)

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.

The survey findings highlighted a gender gap among those who recognized Pakistan Post. Eighty percent of men recognized Pakistan Post compared with only 51% of women. While similar gender gaps exist in the recognition of the other entities, it is important to highlight that Pakistan Post had the highest level of recognition among women when compared with recognition for other institutions.

When it comes to services offered by Pakistan Post, survey results show that, while 93% of those who recognize the institution were aware of mail services, far fewer are aware of financial services, such as money orders (25%), savings accounts (13%), and insurance (7%) (Figure 2).

Figure 2: Recognition of Pakistan Post Services (n=2337)

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.

Low levels of awareness of the financial services offered by Pakistan post are also seen among users of alternative financial services. For instance, only 19% of those who use mobile money to send or receive money knew that Pakistan Post offers electronic money orders. Similarly, only 22% of those with bank accounts knew that Pakistan Post also offers savings accounts.

2. Trust in Pakistan Post

Trust is a crucial factor in financial transactions, and given Pakistan Post’s official government status, as well as its brick-and-mortar structures, it is not surprising that the institution enjoys a relatively high level of trust compared to alternative money transfer services. Figure 3 compares the overall levels of trust expressed for Pakistan Post, mobile money agents and hawala/hundi2 agents, among those who knew about these services and willing to express their opinions.

Figure 3: Trust level comparisons

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.

The survey results showed a higher proportion (40%) of respondents “fully trusted” the Pakistan Post versus the proportion (35%) who “fully trusted” mobile money agents. However, Pakistan Post and mobile money agents, both representing the formal financial sector, enjoy much higher levels of trust than hundi/hawala agents, who work outside of the formal financial services network.

Figure 4: Trust comparison, mobile money and post office (n=246)

The FII surveyed allowed for a closer look at money transfer services and the relative trust in mobile money versus Pakistan Post (see Figure 4). Respondents who were aware of (but not necessarily users of) Pakistan Post’s electronic money order service were asked who they would trust more when making a money transfer – mobile money agents or Pakistan Post. Statistically there was little difference between the proportion of respondents who said they would trust mobile money agents more than Pakistan Post, and vice versa. The largest portion of respondents (39%) said they have equal trust in mobile money agents and Pakistan Post.

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.

The survey data from actual users shows that 29% of users of money transfers from both Pakistan Post and mobile money providers have greater trust in Pakistan Post (Figure 5), versus 35% who would trust a mobile money agent more, and 32% who would trust both equally. Among those who only use either mobile money or Pakistan Post for money transfers, familiarity breeds trust – 52% of those who only use mobile money trust it more than Pakistan Post, and 36% of those who only use Pakistan Post trust it more than mobile money.

Figure 5: Trust comparison between users of mobile money and Pakistan Post

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.

To better evaluate the competitiveness of mobile money transfers with Pakistan Post, it is also important to highlight the increased trust in mobile money agents seen in the 2020 FII survey compared to the first FII survey in 2013 (see Figure 6). The compares the trust levels shown for mobile money agents in 2020 versus 2013.

Figure 6: Increasing trust levels in mobile money agents

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.

These increasing trust levels could be a result of the increasing usage of mobile money in Pakistan, as data from the State Bank of Pakistan shows, the value of mobile money transactions has increased from PKR 67 billion at the end of FY 2012-133 to PKR 467 billion by the third quarter of 2019-204

3. Appeal for rural population

The management at Pakistan Post seems hopeful that the rural population would be more at ease at a Pakistan Post branch as compared to a more corporate-branded bank branch. The survey findings showed both urban and rural populations would be more at ease using financial services at a bank compared to a post office (Figure 7). However, a smaller proportion of rural Pakistan vs. urban residents prefer banks. Another peculiar aspect of the rural response is that 43% of the respondents did not have a clear preference between these two options.

Figure 7: Rural and urban preferences for availing financial services

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.

However, when we look at rural users of Pakistan Post’s financial services, we see less of a gap between the preference for a bank versus a preference for Pakistan Post. However, even the users of Pakistan Post’s financial services prefer availing financial services at a bank versus at Pakistan Post (Figure 8).

Figure 8: Preferences of rural users of Pakistan Post's financial services (n=303)

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.

4. Satisfaction with Pakistan Post services

Users of Pakistan Post’s services exhibit a very high level of satisfaction with its services. Interestingly, the satisfaction level seems to be higher for financial services than postal services (Figure 9).

Figure 9: Satisfaction level with Pakistan Post's postal and financial services

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020; Wave 1 (N=6,000,15+), November 2013-January 2014

However, awareness of Pakistan Post’s savings account remains low among the financially excluded. Based on FII 2020, only 4% of the financially excluded knew about the savings account offering at the Pakistan Post. Figure 10 lists the main reasons why this sample of financially excluded respondents did not have a savings account at the Pakistan Post, despite knowing about its existence. Seventeen percent of the financially excluded did not opt for a savings account because they did not understand the registration procedures.

Figure 10: Reasons for not having a Pakistan Post Savings Account (n=121)

Source: Kantar Pakistan FII Tracker survey, Wave 6 (N=3,567, 15+), February – March 2020.

Conclusion:

Pakistan Post has one of the highest levels of recognition among government entities. However, that recognition is mostly limited to its postal and courier delivery role; awareness of its financial services remains low. Internally, it is believed that Pakistan Post’s money transfer products would have an advantage over mobile money P2P products because Pakistan Post offices would be the more trustworthy option when compared with mobile money agents. Similarly, it is believed the Pakistan Post offices would be more accessible when compared to the branches of commercial banks. However, FII 2020 found evidence to the contrary in both cases. The FII 2020 survey also found that users of Pakistan Post’s financial services show a high level of satisfaction, however, the low awareness of its financial products may be acting as a barrier to adoption among the financially excluded.

Recommendation: Pakistan Post could boost the adoption of its financial products through increased marketing about its financial products as well as their registration processes.

Notes

1 Note: Due to the onset of COVID-19 in Pakistan, the data collection was reduced from its original target of 6,000 individuals.

2 Hawala and Hundi agents are informal agents who offer money transfer services.

3 Payment Systems Review – FY 2013-14 – State Bank of Pakistan, http://www.sbp.org.pk/PS/PDF/FiscalYear-2013-14.pdf

4 Payment Systems Review – January to March FY 2019-20, https://www.sbp.org.pk/PS/PDF/PS-Review-Q3FY20.pdf

Analytical note dated 27 September 2020. Figures reflect the data available at the time.

Filed under:

Leave a Reply