Peshawar valley has recently been subjected to an interesting analysis, where the region is declared a part of “Pakistan-proper”, i.e. a region that is a beneficiary of the State’s policies and priorities. Reasons quoted for this are its connectivity to the GT road, the over-representation of Peshawar valley in Government jobs and higher ranking on development indicators among Pashtun majority districts. This argument is then extended by some Pashtun nationalists to claim that the interests and politics of Peshawar valley is more in-line with the priorities of Pakistan-proper than with the Pashtun peripheries. However, a look at relevant statistics and historical realities paints a different picture.
These arguments take a very quasi-orientalist lens to this situation, where they assume all Pashtun regions to be at the same level of pre-1947 development. Once seen from that angle, Peshawar’s present development indicators would seem like a post-1947 phenomenon where Peshawar prospered along with its GT road compatriots in Punjab to outpace other Pashtun majority regions, such as D. I. Khan and Quetta.
However, the fact is that Peshawar, due to its geographic location and as a central trading hub, has long been a preferred seat of administration for different kingdoms throughout history. This history goes back to the days of the Gandhara civilization (6th century BCE), it was also the capital of the Kushan Empire (2nd Century CE) and the winter capital for the Durranis (1770s). This prominence over the centuries has resulted in it being one of the longest surviving cities in South Asia. In comparison, both Quetta and D. I. Khan rose to prominence in the late 1800s, after they became British cantonments. Any present-day comparison of the levels of development amongst these regions should not ignore their levels of development before 1947.
To put things in perspective, let’s look at some indicators from the pre-1947 British Gazetteers. One relevant indicator is the population density, and this is important because regions that are better at supporting human population tend to have a more developed infrastructure and business opportunities to support the population. On this measure Peshawar had 3021 persons per square miles in 1901. This was substantially higher than Hazara at 1852, D. I. Khan at 663 and Quetta at 224. A comparable district to Peshawar on this measure was Lahore at 3145 persons per square mile. Similarly, another relevant indicator could be the presence of metaled roads in 1903-04, and on this Peshawar scored at 6.016 miles of metaled roads per 100 square miles of area, substantially higher than Hazara at 3.157, D.I. Khan at 2.888 and Quetta at 1.139. Here again, Lahore was a close comparator at 5.3710.
Population density, 1901
Persons per square mile, 1901 (British Gazetteers)
Peshawar was almost as densely populated as Lahore (302 vs 314 persons per square mile).
Metalled roads, 1903–04
Miles of metalled road per 100 square miles of area, 1903–04 (British Gazetteers)
Peshawar had the densest metalled road network of the five, ahead of Lahore.
Therefore, if any post-partition comparisons of development are to be carried out, then Peshawar should be compared with the likes of Lahore and not D. I. Khan and Quetta. And when that comparison is carried out, Peshawar is found to be lagging severely behind Lahore, i.e. the real “Pakistan-proper”. A recent working paper11 from the World Bank reported a poverty rate of 25.9% for Peshawar, much higher than the 3.8% for Lahore, and this is despite Peshawar’s GT Road connectivity and its over representation in Government jobs.
Poverty rate, 2019–20
Share of the population in poverty, 2019–20 (World Bank poverty map)
Peshawar’s poverty rate is almost seven times Lahore’s.
Interestingly, Quetta’s incidence of poverty (23.3%) was a bit lower than Peshawar, and this is not the only indicator where this Pashtun periphery scored higher than Peshawar. The PSLM 2019-20 shows that Quetta surpasses Peshawar on; literacy (10+), fuels for cooking and lighting, solid waste collection, and is within the margin of error for several others. All of this was achieved without any access to GT Road. So, does this make Quetta a part of “Pakistan proper” as well, and its priorities and politics not reflective of a Pashtun periphery?
Being part of what social scientists call an “in-group” (read Pakistan-proper) is not merely about poverty and infrastructure, it’s about the alignment of interests. To be the “in-group” the group’s interests need to align with the priorities of the State, if they don’t, then they are the “out-group” (read periphery)12. Understanding the interests of Peshawar requires an understanding of the region’s ancient role of being the toll booth that connected Central Asia to South Asia. It was this role that secured its relevance for centuries and generated its wealth. This is not just an irrelevant footnote for this region, trade revenues have always been as central for Peshawar, as agriculture and industrial revenues have been for the districts on the Punjab side of the GT road.
The arrival of the British and the start of the “great game” between the British and Russian empires negatively impacted this central lifeline for Peshawar. It transformed Peshawar from being part of the in-group for most of its history to a frontier periphery that was to be a militarized staging ground for imperial games in Afghanistan. On the other hand, the Punjab side of GT road received investments in agriculture and industries such as cotton spinning and weaving, railway repairs, iron foundries, oil and flour mills, etc.
This pre-independence distribution of roles along the GT road has continued after 1947 as well. The closure of Torkham still deals a devastating blow to Peshawar’s economy but is almost a non-issue for other districts on the GT road. Other costs of Afghanistan related strategic games are also overwhelmingly borne by Peshawar and have introduced debilitating insecurity in the region. According to data from the Global Terrorism Database13, Peshawar alone accounted for 13% of all War on Terror (WoT) related terrorist incidents and 14% of the resulting fatalities in Pakistan from 2001 to 2021. Making it the worst hit district in Pakistan when it comes to terrorism. Taliban’s abduction and extortion campaigns have been beside this, and the combined effect of these has resulted in an exodus of both physical as well as human capital from Peshawar Valley and mostly towards other districts on the GT road. The access to GT road and a few thousand government jobs could not save Peshawar from this fate and it cannot compensate for all these losses by any stretch of the imagination. Goes without saying that if Peshawar was truly part of “Pakistan-proper”, it would not have been left to absorb these costs for decades.
It is because of the resulting discontent from these policies that Peshawar Valley has been at the fore of anti-establishment struggles even before partition. Under the leadership of Bacha Khan, this region posed perhaps the biggest political challenge to the British in present day Pakistan. This anti-center fervor continued after independence and Wali Khan’s Peshawar valley support base enabled him to build strong alliances with periphery ethnicities, especially the Baloch, against the establishment. Even the not-on-the-same-page-anymore PTI is also increasingly using Pashtun nationalist talking points to whip up support in Peshawar valley.
This has not been the case with the other GT road districts, which have always aligned with the center; from the loyalist Unionists of Colonial Punjab to the present day “same-page” of PML-N. Many explain this stark contrast in cultural terms, but such explanations overlook the mobilization and resistance of Punjabis in India, where they are an out-group (periphery). From the farmers movement to the Khalistan movement, Punjabis in India have mobilized to defend their interests, their kin just across the border don’t because they don’t feel the need for it, and it is this lack of a need to mobilize is what defines “Pakistan-proper”, not some random survey results on infrastructure or poverty.
So, is Peshawar a part of Pakistan-proper? Well, if that membership depended on a few development indicators, then Quetta’s politics and priorities should also be not considered as those of the peripheries, but stating so would not hold up to scrutiny. The same is true for Peshawar. Being a part of the in-group is about the alignment of interests with the center: a region can sit on the same central highway as the in-group yet still be treated like a periphery. Peshawar is a prime example of this phenomenon.
This article was first published in Profit, Pakistan Today on 24 August 2026.
Notes
1 Source: Imperial Gazetteer of India, Provincial Series: North West Frontier Province (1908). Population = 788,707 (Table V: Distribution of Population, Page 84). Total District area = 2,611 square miles and Population Density = 302 persons per square mile (Section The People — Page 150) ↩
2 Source: Imperial Gazetteer of India, Provincial Series: North West Frontier Province (1908). Population = 528,666 (Table V: Distribution of Population, Page 84). Total administered area (doesn’t include Tanawal) = 2,858 square miles and Population Density = 185 persons per square mile (Section The People — Page 130) ↩
3 Source: Imperial Gazetteer of India, Provincial Series: North West Frontier Province (1908). Population = 247,857 (Table V: Distribution of Population, Page 84). Total District area = 3,780 square miles and Population Density = 66 persons per square mile (Section The People — Page 199) ↩
4 Source: Baluchistan District Gazetteer Series, Volume V: Quetta-Pishin District (1907). Population = 114,087 (Chapter I: Descriptive, Section Population, Page 52). Total District area = 5,127 square miles and Population Density = 22 persons per square mile (Section Population — Page 52) ↩
5 Source: Imperial Gazetteer of India, Provincial Series: Punjab (1908), Volume II. Population = 1,162,109 (Table III: Distribution of Population, Page 152). Total District area = 3,704 square miles and Population Density = 314 persons per square mile (Table III: Distribution of Population — Page 152) ↩
6 Source: Imperial Gazetteer of India, Provincial Series: North West Frontier Province (1908). Population = 788,707 (Table V: Distribution of Population, Page 84). Total District area = 2,611 square miles and Metaled roads = 157 miles (Section Communications — Page 154) ↩
7 Source: Imperial Gazetteer of India, Provincial Series: North West Frontier Province (1908). Population = 528,666 (Section: The People, Page 129). Total District area (doesn’t include Tanawal) = 2,858 square miles and Metalled roads = 90 miles (Section Means of Communications — Page 134) ↩
8 Source: Imperial Gazetteer of India, Provincial Series: North West Frontier Province (1908). Population = 247,857 (Section: The People, Page 199). Total District area = 3,780 square miles and Metalled roads = 109 miles (Section: Communications — Page 202) ↩
9 Source: Balochistan District Gazetteer Series (1907), Volume V. Population = 114,087 (Section: Chapter 1: Migration, Page 53). Total District area = 5,127 square miles and Metalled roads = 57.88 miles (Section Chapter II: Roads Table — Page 208) ↩
10 Source: Imperial Gazetteer of India, Provincial Series: Punjab (1908), Volume II. Population = 1,162,109 (Section: Lahore District Table of Population, Page 19). Total District area = 3,704 square miles and Metalled roads = 199 miles (Section: Means of Communications — Page 24) ↩
11 World Bank, “Pakistan Poverty Map 2019-2020”, Policy Research Working Paper 11012 (2025), by Ramiro Malaga Ortega, Mortiz Meyer, and Paul Corral Rodas https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099537112302466985/pdf/IDU-07c57205-00f2-4d40-9f7f-e4b6997ef579.pdf ↩
12 “A structural Theory of Imperialism,” John Galtung, Journal of Peace Research 8, no. 2 (1971): 81-117, https://www.transcend.org/tms/2020/11/a-structural-theory-of-imperialism/ ↩
13 Global Terrorism Database (GTD), National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism (START), University of Maryland, https://www.start.umd.edu/data-tools/GTD. Author’s calculations. ↩

Leave a Reply